HORL 3: The Ultimate Knife Sharpener Comparison

1 comment View featured products

Premium Sharpeners for Everyday Kitchens


Magnetic precision rolling sharpeners: Cruise vs Oak/Walnut vs Pro

TL;DR - Which HORL 3 Model Is Right for You?

HORL 3 Cruise (£99): Fixed discs, recycled ocean plastic, dual angles 15°/20°, perfect for budget-conscious cooks wanting reliable results. HORL 3 Oak/Walnut (£169): Interchangeable discs via Quick Lock, ceramic honing, premium wood, ideal for home cooks wanting versatility and beauty. HORL 3 Pro (£399): Six adjustable angles (10°-25°), 3x faster via planetary gears, ultimate precision for professionals. All feature 80% more effective diamonds and 70% more grip than HORL 2.

The HORL Principle: Magnetic Precision That Actually Works

HORL has been around for a little while now and is one of the most beautiful, most consistent, and most expensive knife sharpeners on the market. There's a reason for that expense: it actually works extraordinarily well.

It centres around a sound principle: a strong magnet holds the knife blade upside down at a very precise angle of either 15 degrees or 20 degrees (as a rough guide, Japanese knives at 15 degrees, European blades at 20 degrees). You then roll a diamond-coated sharpening surface along the length of the blade.

This rolling action gradually or swiftly (depending on the blade's condition) puts back a very precise and consistent angled sharp edge. The magnetic holder ensures the angle remains perfect throughout sharpening, eliminating the primary challenge of traditional whetstones where maintaining consistent angle requires considerable skill.

Just How Sharp Are We Talking?

When I say sharp, that's not exaggerating in any way. It can be a little unbelievable just how sharp HORL makes your knives. Customers consistently report genuine surprise at the edge quality achieved.

For ultimate perfection, the two stones that HORL 3 comes with may be insufficient depending on your level of expectation. You may find yourself buying one or more of the Fine, Extra Fine, or Ultra Fine stones/discs. But for most home cooks, the standard discs deliver results that exceed requirements.

What Bob, a Long-Standing Customer, Says:

"I bought my Horl last year and, whilst reasonably expensive, I can truly say that I have found it great value for money and one of my best additions to the kitchen armoury! The action is smooth and gives consistently sharp knives. I feel that the reason is that, with the magnetic knife holder, the blade is held firmly at the correct angle. This, in my opinion, isn't really achieved in any other type of sharpener."

"My one observation is that the honing wheel seemed to take a long time to get the 'last bit' done, so I opted to buy a fine stone to replace it which I have found to be ideal."

"On a purely aesthetic note, I am a minimalist in my kitchen with clear surfaces the norm, but this sharpener is truly tactile and is a thing of beauty to be seen as much as used!"

The Problem HORL Solves

If you've been struggling with dull kitchen knives, you know the frustration of trying to dice an onion or slice through a tomato with a blade that's lost its edge. Traditional whetstones require skill and practice that many home cooks never develop. Pull-through sharpeners can damage precious blades through aggressive material removal and inconsistent angles.

HORL's innovative rolling knife sharpeners have revolutionized home knife maintenance by making professional-quality sharpening accessible to everyone, regardless of skill level.

HORL 3 knife sharpener demonstrating rolling action with magnetic precision

What's New in HORL 3? Three Key Improvements

The HORL 3 series introduces significant upgrades over the respected HORL 2. These aren't minor tweaks but genuine improvements that make real differences in daily use.

1. Enhanced Grip and Comfort

  • Wider Design: Approximately one centimetre wider than HORL 2, providing more comfortable grip and better control
  • HORL Grip Pad: Delivers 70% more grip on the magnetic angle support - a substantial improvement
  • Improved Magnetic Strength: Even small paring knives stay firmly in place during sharpening without slipping

This wider design and enhanced grip make extended sharpening sessions more comfortable and provide better control for precision work.

2. Revolutionary Quick Lock Mechanism

  • One-Twist Disc Replacement: Swap sharpening discs with a simple twist instead of the more involved process required with HORL 2
  • Faster Transitions: Easily move between different grit levels for comprehensive knife care
  • Important Note: HORL 2 discs are not compatible with HORL 3 sharpeners due to this new mechanism

Available on Oak/Walnut and Pro models only. The Cruise features fixed discs.

3. Superior Diamond Sharpening Technology

  • HORL Block Diamonds: New diamond layer offers 80% more effectiveness than HORL 2 diamond sharpening stones
  • More Uniform Grinding Pattern: Ensures consistent, precise results with every use along the entire blade length
  • Improved Speed: Sharpens blades more efficiently, saving time in the kitchen

This diamond improvement appears across all HORL 3 models, from the entry-level Cruise to the premium Pro.

HORL 3 Cruise: The Sustainable All-Rounder

HORL 3 Cruise Knife Sharpener

Budget-Conscious Excellence with Environmental Credentials

£99.00

  • New dual-angle support: 15° (Japanese knives) and 20° (Western knives)
  • Eco-friendly construction from #tide Ocean Material® - 100% recycled plastic collected from beaches
  • Fixed (non-interchangeable) diamond sharpening and stainless steel honing discs
  • 80% more effective diamonds with uniform grinding pattern
  • 70% more grip on magnetic angle support
  • Approximately 1cm wider than HORL 2 for better comfort
  • Improved magnetic strength secures even small paring knives
Best For: Budget-conscious cooks who want reliable sharpening without premium features. Perfect for Western knives all types, and Japanese knives with Rockwell hardness above 60 (like Tojiro).

What the Cruise Does Brilliantly

The HORL 3 Cruise delivers reliable, straightforward sharpening performance at an accessible price point. This entry-level model is perfect for those new to knife sharpening or anyone seeking quality results without premium features.

Designed with simplicity in mind, the Cruise features fixed discs that provide consistent results without the complexity of interchangeable components. You cannot swap to different grits, but for most home cooks, the included diamond sharpening and stainless steel honing discs handle everyday knife maintenance perfectly well.

The improved magnetic angle support now offers both 15° and 20° options, making it versatile enough for both Japanese and Western knives. The upgraded diamond sharpening disc boasts the same 80% more abrasive black diamonds with uniform grinding pattern found in premium models, significantly enhancing both speed and precision.

HORL 3 Cruise knife sharpener made from recycled ocean plastic

The Environmental Advantage

Environmentally conscious cooks will appreciate the eco-friendly housing made from ocean-bound recycled plastic. Swiss company #tide collects this plastic from beaches before it reaches the ocean, representing genuine sustainability rather than greenwashing.

This recycled construction doesn't compromise performance. The Cruise delivers the same diamond effectiveness and magnetic grip improvements as premium models, just without interchangeable discs and with stainless steel rather than ceramic honing.

The Honest Limitation

The stainless steel honing disc works best with Japanese knives that have Rockwell hardness above 60 (such as Tojiro), rather than extremely hard options like Kai Shun, Miyabi, or Blenheim Forge. For those very hard Japanese knives, consider the Oak/Walnut or Pro models with ceramic honing discs.

For Western knives of all types, the HORL 3 Cruise delivers excellent, reliable results every time. At £99, it represents exceptional value for most home cooks.

HORL 3 Oak/Walnut: The Versatile Classic

HORL 3 Oak/Walnut Knife Sharpener

Perfect Balance of Aesthetics and Functionality

£169.00

  • Premium materials: Beautiful German oak (Black Forest) or American walnut
  • Interchangeable discs via Quick Lock one-twist mechanism
  • Ceramic honing disc - superior to Cruise's stainless steel disc
  • Dual-angle support: 15° for Japanese knives, 20° for Western blades
  • 80% more abrasive black diamonds with uniform grinding pattern
  • 70% more grip strength on magnetic angle support
  • Approximately 1cm wider design for superior comfort and control
  • Compatible with Fine, Extra Fine, Ultra Fine upgrade stones
Best For: Home cooks and chefs who want quality, versatility, and beautiful design. Ideal for those maintaining diverse knife collections requiring different grit levels.

What Makes Oak/Walnut Outstanding

The HORL 3 Oak/Walnut offers the perfect balance of versatility, precision, and ease of use for both home cooks and professional chefs. Whether you're new to knife sharpening or an experienced whetstone user, this exceptional tool delivers professional results without the lengthy learning curve.

What makes the HORL 3 truly outstanding is its incredible adaptability. The redesigned magnetic angle support features both 15° and 20° angles, making it ideal for both delicate Japanese knives and robust Western blades. The innovative Quick Lock mechanism allows you to easily swap between different grit stones - upgrade to higher-grit discs for ultra-refined edges or switch to lower-grit options to restore chipped or severely dull blades.

HORL 3 Walnut knife sharpener with American walnut finish

The Ceramic Honing Advantage

The ceramic honing disc represents a significant upgrade over the Cruise's stainless steel disc. Ceramic provides finer honing that's particularly valuable for very hard Japanese knives like Kai Shun, Miyabi, or Blenheim Forge that the Cruise struggles with.

This ceramic disc removes burrs and refines edges to perfection, working effectively across all blade types and hardness levels. Combined with the diamond sharpening disc, you have everything needed for comprehensive knife care.

A Statement Piece for Your Kitchen

Crafted with premium materials, the HORL 3 features beautiful solid wood finish. The Oak version uses German oak sourced from the Black Forest with lighter, golden-brown appearance. The Walnut version features American walnut with darker, richer colouring and more pronounced grain patterns.

As Bob noted in his testimonial, "this sharpener is truly tactile and is a thing of beauty to be seen as much as used." The Oak/Walnut models serve as statement pieces for your kitchen as much as practical tools.

Both wood options are functionally identical. Choose based on which finish better matches your kitchen aesthetic - lighter Oak for Scandinavian or contemporary styles, darker Walnut for traditional or luxury kitchens.

HORL 3 Oak knife sharpener with German Black Forest oak finish

The Expandable System

The Quick Lock mechanism makes expanding your disc collection effortless. If you find yourself wanting finer edges, simply purchase Fine, Extra Fine, or Ultra Fine stones and swap them in with one twist. This flexibility future-proofs your investment.

For most users, the included diamond and ceramic discs are sufficient. But knowing you can easily upgrade provides peace of mind and accommodation for evolving needs.

HORL 3 Pro: The Speed Demon

HORL 3 Pro Knife Sharpener

Pinnacle of Precision Sharpening Technology

£399.00

  • Six adjustable angles: 10°, 13°, 15°, 20°, 22°, and 25° for ultimate versatility
  • Revolutionary planetary gear mechanism sharpens 3x faster than standard HORL 3
  • Premium powder-coated aluminium with elegant dark bronze finish
  • Optimized mechanics: perfected drive components and reduced flywheel mass
  • Enhanced diamond disc with 80% more abrasive black diamonds
  • Ceramic honing disc removes burrs and refines edges to perfection
  • Quick Lock mechanism for effortless disc swapping
  • 70% more grip on redesigned magnetic angle support
  • Precision engineering inspired by fine timepieces
Best For: Professional chefs seeking efficiency during busy shifts, and serious home cooks who demand nothing but the best in speed and precision.

What Sets the Pro Apart

The HORL 3 Pro represents the pinnacle of precision sharpening technology for discerning home cooks and professional chefs. With its revolutionary planetary gear mechanism, this premium sharpener delivers results three times faster than standard models, transforming dull blades into razor-sharp edges in seconds.

This speed advantage isn't just marketing hype. The planetary gear system creates more sharpening passes along the blade with each roll, genuinely delivering three times the efficiency. For professional chefs during busy shifts needing quick edge restoration, or home cooks maintaining large knife collections, this time savings is transformative.

HORL 3 Pro knife sharpener with dark bronze finish

Six Angles for Ultimate Versatility

What truly distinguishes the Pro is its versatile six-angle magnetic support system: 10°, 13°, 15°, 20°, 22°, and 25°. This allows you to customize the perfect edge for any knife in your collection.

The finer angles (10°-15°) create precision edges ideal for Japanese knives and delicate tasks like sushi preparation. The wider angles (20°-25°) provide durability for Western knives, meat cleavers, and even non-culinary blades like hunting knives or outdoor tools.

This angle range accommodates knives that the standard 15°/20° options simply cannot properly serve. If you own specialty Japanese knives requiring 10° edges, or heavy-duty cleavers needing 25° durability, the Pro is your only option.

Engineering Excellence

The enhanced diamond disc features 80% more abrasive black diamonds with uniform grinding pattern, dramatically improving both speed and precision. Combined with the planetary gear mechanism, this creates sharpening performance that feels almost effortless.

The ceramic honing disc removes burrs and refines edges to perfection. The optimized mechanics with reduced flywheel mass make the faster action feel controlled and smooth rather than aggressive.

Crafted from powder-coated aluminium with elegant dark bronze finish, the Pro doesn't just perform exceptionally - it looks stunning on your countertop. The precision engineering is inspired by fine timepieces, representing genuine mechanical innovation.

Is the Pro Worth £399?

That's the honest question. At £399, the Pro represents premium pricing that's most justified for professional chefs or serious home cooks who sharpen frequently and maintain diverse collections.

If you primarily use standard Western kitchen knives and sharpen occasionally, the Oak/Walnut at £169 provides better value. But if you: maintain large knife collections requiring various angles, frequently sharpen knives and value time savings, own specialty blades needing 10° or 25° angles, or simply demand the absolute best without compromise - the Pro justifies its price through genuine performance advantages rather than just luxury positioning.

Side-by-Side: Which HORL 3 Is Right for You?

HORL 3 Cruise

£99

  • ✓ Fixed discs
  • ✓ Recycled plastic
  • ✓ 15° & 20° angles
  • ✓ Stainless steel honing
  • ✓ 80% more diamonds
  • ✓ 70% more grip
  • × No Quick Lock
  • × No disc upgrades

HORL 3 Oak/Walnut

£169

  • ✓ Interchangeable discs
  • ✓ Premium wood
  • ✓ 15° & 20° angles
  • ✓ Ceramic honing
  • ✓ 80% more diamonds
  • ✓ 70% more grip
  • ✓ Quick Lock system
  • ✓ Upgrade stones available

HORL 3 Pro

£399

  • ✓ Six angle options
  • ✓ Aluminium bronze
  • ✓ 10°-25° range
  • ✓ Ceramic honing
  • ✓ 80% more diamonds
  • ✓ 70% more grip
  • ✓ Quick Lock system
  • ✓ 3x faster sharpening
Feature Cruise Oak/Walnut Pro
Price £99.00 £169.00 £399.00
Angle Options 15° & 20° 15° & 20° 10°, 13°, 15°, 20°, 22°, 25°
Disc System Fixed (non-interchangeable) Quick Lock interchangeable Quick Lock interchangeable
Honing Disc Stainless steel Ceramic Ceramic
Sharpening Speed Standard Standard 3x faster (planetary gears)
Material Recycled ocean plastic German oak or American walnut Powder-coated aluminium
Diamond Improvement 80% more effective 80% more effective 80% more effective
Grip Improvement 70% more grip 70% more grip 70% more grip
Upgrade Stones Not compatible Compatible (Fine/Extra Fine/Ultra Fine) Compatible (Fine/Extra Fine/Ultra Fine)
Best For Budget-conscious home cooks Quality-focused home cooks and chefs Professionals and serious enthusiasts

Decision Framework

Choose the Cruise if: You're new to knife sharpening, work primarily with Western knives or moderate-hardness Japanese knives (like Tojiro), want reliable results without premium features, appreciate environmental sustainability, or need to keep costs around £100.

Choose the Oak/Walnut if: You maintain diverse knife collections requiring different grit levels, own very hard Japanese knives needing ceramic honing, want the flexibility to upgrade stones later, value beautiful design as much as function, or seek the sweet spot between price and versatility at £169.

Choose the Pro if: You're a professional chef needing quick edge restoration during shifts, maintain large collections and sharpen frequently, own specialty knives requiring 10° or 25° angles, value time savings from 3x faster sharpening, or simply demand the absolute best without compromise at £399.

How to Use HORL: The Marker Test

The first time you use the HORL sharpener on a knife, it's essential to "teach" your knife the new angles. This simple marker test takes less than 10 minutes and ensures optimal results.

The Marker Test Process

  1. Mark the Blade: Colour the very edge of the blade with a marker pen, on both sides. This shows exactly where the sharpening disc removes material.
  2. Sharpen: Use the coarse diamond disc to sharpen one side until the marker is completely gone, keeping careful track of the number of strokes.
  3. Repeat: Do the same for the other side, ensuring all the marker is removed. Use the same number of strokes for consistency.
  4. Hone: Hone the blade using the same number of strokes you used for sharpening. No need to mark the blade for honing.

Important: Do this marker test every time you introduce a new knife to the HORL sharpener. Once a knife has been "taught" the HORL angles, subsequent sharpening sessions are straightforward.

General Sharpening Guidelines

Use 15 degrees for Japanese knives and 20 degrees for Western/European blades as a rough guide. The HORL 3 Pro's six-angle system allows finer customization: 10°-15° creates precision edges for Japanese knives and delicate tasks, whilst 20°-25° provides durability for Western knives and heavy-duty applications.

The rolling action should be smooth and consistent. Let the diamond disc do the work - excessive force isn't necessary with the enhanced 80% more effective diamonds. The magnetic angle support ensures precise angle maintenance, so focus on smooth, even strokes along the blade length.

Why Buy HORL from Art of Living?

  • Over 50 Years Expertise - Family-owned since 1972, we understand quality knife care
  • HORL Specialists - We can demonstrate rolling action and help choose the right model
  • No-Quibble Returns - Try HORL sharpeners out, return for refund if not satisfied
  • Three Surrey Locations - See and handle all three HORL 3 models at Reigate, Cobham, and Redhill stores
  • Expert Advice - Our staff explain magnetic angle precision and help match sharpeners to your knives
  • Complete Range - Cruise, Oak, Walnut, and Pro models in stock, plus upgrade stones
  • Additional Stones Available - Fine, Extra Fine, and Ultra Fine stones for ultimate perfection

Find Your Perfect HORL 3 Sharpener

Magnetic precision rolling sharpeners from £99. Cruise for budget-conscious excellence, Oak/Walnut for versatile quality, Pro for ultimate performance.

Shop HORL 3 → Expert Advice →

Final Thoughts: Magnetic Precision That Transforms Knife Care

HORL 3 sharpeners represent genuine innovation in knife maintenance. The magnetic angle support eliminates the primary challenge of traditional sharpening - maintaining consistent angles. The rolling action is intuitive. The results are unbelievably sharp.

The three-model range serves different needs without artificial market segmentation. The Cruise at £99 delivers reliable performance with environmental credentials. The Oak/Walnut at £169 provides versatile quality with beautiful design. The Pro at £399 offers professional-grade speed and six-angle precision.

All three share the core HORL 3 improvements: 80% more effective diamonds, 70% more grip, and approximately one centimetre wider design. These upgrades make real differences in daily use.

Whether you're frustrated with dull knives, disappointed by whetstone results, or seeking professional-quality edges without lengthy learning curves, HORL 3 deserves serious consideration. Combined with our no-quibble guarantee, there's no risk in discovering whether HORL transforms your knife care as it has for countless customers who report it being "one of my best additions to the kitchen armoury."

Visit our Surrey stores to see and handle all three models, or shop online with confidence knowing we back every HORL purchase with comprehensive support and expert guidance.


1 comment


  • PETER

    Been looking at the Horl 3 and the Katana Saya Roller Sharpener £79 at kitchen knives.
    Do you know anything about this model.
    Also whichever one I get am also looking to get one for son as well.
    Any discount on a purchase of two Horl 3 oak please

    kind regards,

    peter


Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.


Unique tag count: 374

Search the Blog



Popular Searches